What to Read After My Immortal
Readers who loved My Immortal by Erin McCarthy keep reaching for these 24 books. This list is built from where My Immortal is read alongside other books across reader co-reads and book lists. The more independent sources agree on a title, the higher it ranks.
Books to read after My Immortal
Fallen (Seven Deadly Sins, Book 2)
Demon can't help it
Heiress for Hire
Tempt Me with Darkness
Gentlemen Prefer Succubi
A date with the other side
Mouth To Mouth
You Don't Know Jack
Houston, we have a problem
The Demon King and I
Eternal Pleasure
Flat-Out Sexy
Hard and Fast
Any Way You Want It
Bad Boys of Summer
Don't Talk Back To Your Vampire
First Blood
Bad Boys Online
A Pirate's Pleasure
Witch heart
My man, Michael
Witch Blood (Elemental Witches, Book 2)
Bad Boys in Black Tie
The Secret Life of Bryan