What to Read After Penpal
Readers who loved Penpal by Dathan Auerbach keep reaching for these 24 books. This list is built from where Penpal is read alongside other books across reader co-reads and book lists. The more independent sources agree on a title, the higher it ranks.
Books to read after Penpal
Naomi's Room
A Head Full of Ghosts
Incarnate
White Is for Witching
This Book is Full of Spiders
John Dies at the End
Horrorstör
The Troop
Heart-Shaped Box
Summer of Night
NOS4A2
20th Century Ghosts
Hell House
Broken Monsters
The Girl Next Door
Disappearance at Devil's Rock
The Ruins
The Elementals
Hex (Robert Grim #1)
House of Leaves
Off Season
The Deep
Walkers
The Imago Sequence and Other Stories